News

Fuel indexation in road haulage: Spain, Italy and France mandate it, Germany leaves it to the parties

When diesel prices surged in spring 2026, hauliers across Europe faced the same question: who bears the risk of higher fuel costs once a freight rate has been agreed? A rate agreed in February no longer covered a haul performed in April. What they could do about it depended on the law governing the contract. Some countries give the carrier a statutory right to adjust the price; in others the carrier gets nothing beyond what was negotiated.

Since April, two Member States have tightened their rules and a third has announced that it will. Spain acted first: a royal decree-law of 14 April 2026 rewrote the price-revision provision of its Land Transport Contract Act. Spanish freight prices must now be revised automatically, up or down, whenever the diesel price moves by 5% or more between contract and performance. The parties may agree a lower threshold, but not a higher one, and any clause excluding or limiting the revision is void. In continuing contracts, the price is revised every billing period, however small the change. The fuel adjustment must appear as a separate line on the invoice. A payer who refuses or blocks that line now commits an administrative offence; repeat offenders face fines of up to EUR 18,000.

Italy has required written haulage contracts to contain a fuel clause since 2022: the price is adjusted once diesel moves by more than 2%, and a contract without the clause is treated as not concluded in writing. On 23 October 2026 the government went further. A decree-law on road haulage, agriculture and fisheries obliges the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport to publish each quarter a minimum and a maximum share of fuel in the freight price, broken down by vehicle weight class. For contracts not concluded in writing, the published minimum is binding for services performed from 24 October 2026, and the fuel portion must be shown separately on the invoice. For written contracts concluded from 24 October 2026, the ministerial values serve only as a reference, but the contract must now state the fuel cost at signature and its share of the price. Parliament must convert the decree into law by 22 December 2026, and amendments remain possible until then.

In France, mandatory fuel indexation is long established. The Transport Code revises the agreed price by operation of law, and if the contract is silent, the indices of the Comité national routier fill the gap. The rules are expressly of public policy. The pending reform concerns enforcement. In October the Transport Minister announced that the criminal fine on shippers who ignore indexation, currently EUR 15,000, should give way to administrative penalties of up to EUR 450,000 for companies, imposed by the prefecture. Occasional coach transport is to be brought within the scheme. The government has also announced a ministerial instruction, due by the end of October, that is to list smoothing, tunnel and franchise clauses as incompatible with the statutory indexation regime. A working group is due to propose in early December how the CNR indices could be extended to all future contracts. The Institute has found neither the instruction nor a bill implementing the sanctions reform so far.

Portugal has run a comparable mechanism since 2008, with revision once the reference fuel price moves by more than 5%. Germany remains the outlier. German transport law has no statutory fuel adjustment mechanism, so the freight rate is whatever the parties agreed. Neither the Commercial Code nor the forwarders' standard terms (ADSp 2017) contain a fuel clause. A German haulier who wants a diesel surcharge must negotiate it, typically through the voluntary diesel floater recommended by the haulage association BGL. Without such a clause, the Civil Code's rule on interference with the basis of the transaction offers little: rising procurement costs are ordinarily the supplier's risk.

Cross-border complications

The CMR, which governs most international road carriage, says nothing about the level of the freight price. That issue is governed by the national law designated under the Rome I Regulation. Where the parties have chosen no law, Article 5(1) of that Regulation points to Spanish law for a Spanish carrier's Valencia-to-Dortmund run, because the carrier is established and the goods are loaded in Spain. The German shipper then pays a price that Spanish law revises.

Whether a court in another Member State would apply the French or Spanish rules even against a chosen foreign law, as overriding mandatory provisions, is an open question. The Institute has not been able to identify a judgment that decides the point. The Spanish carriers' association FENADISMER argues that the Spanish regime also applies to CMR carriage to and from Spain, because the Convention leaves the price to national law. That does not answer what happens where the parties have chosen another law.

Contracts and invoices must follow the formal requirements of the governing law: in Spain the separate invoice line, in Italy the fuel cost and share stated in the written contract, in France the fuel charges shown on the invoice. Under French law, claims for unpaid indexation become time-barred after one year. For shippers running pan-European tenders, the choice-of-law clause and the treatment of spot orders under framework agreements have become a cost question. A fixed all-in rate that holds under German law becomes revisable where Spanish or French law governs the contract.